Compassdesigns.net

Teaching - Web - Sailing

  • Home
  • Services

Did Stallman Say Gmail is Worse than Stupidity?

October 28, 2008 By barrie@compassdesigns.net Leave a Comment

At this point, I couldn’t run my business without Gmail. Its increased my productivity tremendously….

Stallman was quoted as saying:

"The classic example of cloud computing might be Gmail, offered by Google."

Stallman says cloud computing forces people to hand over control of their information to a third party. His objections echo his longstanding belief in non-proprietary software. "One reason you should not use Web applications to do your computing is that you lose control," he said. "It’s just as bad as using a proprietary program.

Stallman dismisses cloud computing as industry bluster. "It’s stupidity. It’s worse than stupidity: it’s a marketing hype campaign," he said. "Somebody is saying this is inevitable–and whenever you hear somebody saying that, it’s very likely to be a set of businesses campaigning to make it true."

Now, we all know that Stallman is a great advocate of the GPL. I might suggest his views are…. towards one end of the spectrum, and he represents one camp of thought. Linus Torvalds for example argues a different viewpoint with respect to the GPL.

I don’t want to discuss the GPL here, but do we really think that software-as-service type applications are inherently bad?

  • Gmail?
  • Google docs?
  • Google checkout?
  • Wufoo?
  • Basecamp?
  • Freshbooks?
  • Ning?
  • Facebook?
  • LinkedIn?

These applications are tremendously useful and bring technology to small businesses and individuals who would otherwise not have access to them. They could not afford the dollar and technological investment of using open source software to implement similar services.

I’d argue high quality remote web applications increase freedom by increasing access to those applications.

Was he making a subtle point that I missed, or is Stallman out of touch with todays web? What do you think?

 

Filed Under: Uncategorized

The Skinny

I am an entrepreneur, web consultant, author and educator.

I have been involved in starting a K-12 School District, a Private High School, and three web tech companies. I also wrote one of the original and best selling books on Joomla.

And I like sailing with kids.

Recent Posts

  • Teenager Invents New Type of Hunting Camo Suit
  • A Parent’s Guide to Proficiency Based Learning
  • Proficiency/Competency Based Learning in NGSS Classrooms
  • Hunting Camouflage Website Launched
  • Get More Email Newsletter Signups With These Easy Tips
  • Proficiency Based Learning Resources
  • Social Media Redux
  • How to turn off WordPress Comments if you use Disqus
  • The API was Yesterday. The Tomorrow is iPaaS
  • Left Hook Digital Named Zapier’s First Integration Developer Partner

Top Posts

  • What Exactly is Standards-Based Teaching and Learning
  • Joomla Extension Reviews - Tienda and Anahita
  • Displaying the Joomla Search Results Page with the Correct Template and Modules
  • 22nd Century Learning

Blogroll

See3D Camo

Blaze Orange Camo

Vermont CPR

Copyright © 2023 Compass Designs ยท Musings on Education, Life, Joomla and the Web by Barrie North